The Somali Monitor
Somalia Responds to the UN Over Chief Justice Dismissal
Somalia's government has rejected UN criticism of its removal of the Supreme Court Chief Justice, invoking transitional constitutional powers and procedural irregularities to defend its actions. Yet behind the legal arguments lies a deeper struggle over presidential authority, judicial independence and the legitimacy of the country's contested political transition.

Somalia's Response Letter to the UN, 14 Nov 26
MOGADISHU — November 14, 2026
Somalia's deepening constitutional crisis has entered a new phase of international scrutiny after the Federal Government formally challenged United Nations concerns over the removal of Supreme Court Chief Justice Bashe Yusuf Ahmed. What began as a constitutional petition questioning presidential and parliamentary term extensions has evolved into a broader confrontation over judicial independence, executive authority and the legitimacy of Somalia's political transition.
In its response to a November 12 statement by UN human rights experts, the Ministry of Justice and Constitutional Affairs defended President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's decision to remove the Chief Justice, rejected the legal validity of the Supreme Court's subsequent pronouncements and criticised the UN experts for failing to adequately consult the government. While Mogadishu presents the dispute as a matter of constitutional procedure and institutional transition, its implications are considerably more consequential: the executive is challenging the authority of a judicial institution that has questioned the constitutional basis of its continued tenure.
The confrontation emerged from constitutional amendments approved in March 2026, extending presidential and parliamentary terms from four to five years. Although the government defended the changes as necessary for completing constitutional reforms and transitioning towards direct elections, opposition leaders and some Federal Member States challenged their legality and the absence of political consensus. Former President Sheikh Sharif Sheikh Ahmed subsequently petitioned the Supreme Court, questioning whether the amendments could lawfully extend existing mandates.
The dispute escalated on November 4 when President Mohamud removed Chief Justice Bashe Yusuf Ahmed and reinstated his predecessor, Ibrahim Idle Suleiman, immediately before the Court was expected to address the petition. The following day, a five-judge Supreme Court panel issued pronouncements concluding that the amendments could not automatically extend incumbent mandates, determining that Parliament's tenure had expired on April 14 and the President's on May 15, 2026. The panel also called for an agreed electoral framework within 30 days and restricted the government's authority to caretaker functions. The Attorney General rejected the decision, citing procedural and jurisdictional irregularities.
The timing of the Chief Justice's removal remains central to the controversy. Although the government insists the decision was unrelated to the proceedings, its proximity to a case directly affecting presidential legitimacy raises questions about executive interference in judicial functions. The central issue is not simply whether the President possesses authority to remove senior judicial officials, but whether that authority can be exercised during proceedings involving the President's own constitutional mandate without compromising judicial independence.
The government's defence rests primarily on Somalia's incomplete constitutional architecture. According to the Ministry, the High Council of the Judiciary has not yet been fully established, requiring reliance on transitional arrangements governing judicial appointments and removals. It argues that the Chief Justice was removed through the same mechanism used for his original appointment. Yet this reasoning exposes a deeper constitutional dilemma: whether institutional gaps justify continued executive discretion or whether such discretion risks undermining the judicial safeguards that constitutional reform is intended to establish.
The Ministry also challenged the Supreme Court's November 5 pronouncements on procedural grounds, citing the panel's alleged failure to resolve preliminary questions of jurisdiction and legal standing, comply with hearing requirements and maintain lawful bench composition. It further argued that the Court exceeded the scope of the original petition. Most significantly, the government maintains that once the Chief Justice's removal became effective, he no longer possessed judicial authority, rendering subsequent pronouncements legally invalid. However, this argument depends on the legality of the removal itself—the very action challenged by the UN experts. If the removal was unconstitutional, using it to invalidate judicial proceedings creates a circular legal argument in which a disputed executive decision becomes the basis for rejecting judicial scrutiny.
The UN experts' intervention, led by Special Rapporteurs Margaret Satterthwaite and Ben Saul, reflected concerns extending beyond the removal. Their statement highlighted reported security deployments around the Supreme Court, withdrawal of protection from judges and restrictions on judicial officials' movements. Rather than accepting these conclusions, the government questioned the experts' procedural approach, arguing that Somali authorities had not been adequately consulted. This response seeks to reposition international criticism as a matter of procedural fairness while reinforcing Mogadishu's interpretation of its transitional constitutional authority.
Politically, the confrontation comes as Somalia faces growing pressure to resolve its electoral deadlock, with renewed consultations planned for November 14 in Mogadishu. The Supreme Court's disputed pronouncements have strengthened the opposition's legal challenge to the government's mandate, while the administration continues to defend the validity of the constitutional amendments and its preferred electoral timetable. The absence of a functioning Constitutional Court further complicates the dispute, leaving competing interpretations of constitutional authority without a universally accepted mechanism for resolution.
For President Mohamud, defending the amendments may preserve the government's political and electoral agenda, but rejecting judicial scrutiny risks deepening perceptions of executive overreach. For opposition leaders, the Court's pronouncements provide a potentially significant legal foundation for challenging the administration, although their enforceability remains contested. For international partners, the challenge is to encourage a negotiated settlement while safeguarding judicial independence and constitutional governance.
Ultimately, Somalia's response to the United Nations represents more than a diplomatic rebuttal. It is an effort to defend executive authority, establish the government's interpretation of constitutional legality and challenge a judicial intervention with potentially far-reaching consequences for the current administration. Yet the controversy also exposes the fragility of a constitutional transition in which institutional safeguards remain incomplete and fundamental questions of authority are increasingly settled through political confrontation.
The deeper danger is that Somalia's constitutional crisis may ultimately be determined not by the strength of competing legal arguments, but by which institution possesses the political power to enforce its interpretation. Unless the current confrontation produces a credible constitutional and political settlement, it risks reinforcing the very institutional weaknesses that Somalia's constitutional reforms were intended to overcome.
